Streamlining Interpretations For Healthcare Fire Protection Issues
Project Manager: Gregory E. Harrington
Background and History
As a field surveyor, policy administrator, fire marshal, health care provider, or other authority having jurisdiction, how many times have you received different interpretations from different parties, concerning the same problem? Because of the number and variety of groups that evaluate all aspects of the service, safety and performance of a health care facility, slight (sometimes major) differences in interpretations of applicable codes and standards can arise. The Healthcare Interpretations Task Force (HITF), is now in place to help reconcile organizational differences of opinion.
Formed in July 1998, this Task Force is the by-product of a unique coalition of the major organizations that most impact the health care community in terms of fire protection related issues. This coalition, created in 1996, was originally known as the Authority Having Jurisdiction Committee, was comprised of representatives from:
- American Health Care Association (AHCA)
- American Society for Healthcare Engineering (ASHE)
- Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) (now Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Servces (CMS))
- International Fire Marshals Association (IFMA)
- Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) (now The Joint Commission)
- National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)
- Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)
The purpose was to bring together the organizations that must enforce, implement, abide by or evaluate the various fire protection measures found in nearly every health care occupancy in the U.S. This group has worked on several initiatives including working to make recognition of the 2000 Edition of the Life Safety Code® the formally adopted reference for CMS and more recently the 2012 edition.
Another important area identified where across-the-board communication was deemed essential involved interpretation and understanding of the various NFPA codes and standards used in the health care environment. Use, interpretation and understanding of these documents; the relationship between NFPA criteria and state regulation; and how NFPA rules relate to the position and policy views of groups like CMS and The Joint Commission (TJC) can sometimes be difficult to navigate.
The Healthcare Interpretations Task Force established an original mission, purpose, and process by which the Task Force would operate. In 2020, the Task Force brings together the organizations shown below to evaluate, debate, and engage the resources of the member organizations to establish consistent interpretations of specific issues and questions. The Chair of the Life Safety Code Committee on Health Care Occupancies, the Chair of the Health Care Facilities Correlating Committee, and the Chair of the NFPA Health Care Section also maintain a seat on the HITF. While the debate and discussions on the submitted questions are open to all members, the actual voting by the committee is limited to the nine authority having jurisdiction members; CMS, DOD, DNV, HFAP, IFMA, IHS, TJC, SHA, and VA. In addition, two-thirds of the voting members must be in agreement about a particular answer to a particular question.
The original mission statement, paraphrased below, captures the essence of what the HITF has worked to establish.
MISSION: To provide consistent interpretations on national codes and standards referenced by CMS, JCAHO and state and territorial authorities having jurisdiction. This will be accomplished through the evaluation of field conditions, surveyor/inspector/fire marshal interpretations, and questions by consumers of these services generated through a member of the task force.
The ideals of this original mission are now captured in the Charter and Bylaws of the HITF. In this process, nothing the HITF does is intended to usurp the power or authority of an NFPA Technical Committee who still has ultimate responsibility for rendering formal interpretations to their respective documents. In fact, the task force will actually recommend forwarding unresolved items to the appropriate NFPA Technical Committee for a formal interpretation, or as individual members, recommending changes to NFPA codes and standards to clarify certain issues.
In the normal course of action, the HITF will receive several agenda items for the group to consider and evaluate. As with any code or standard, one's perspective, background and experience may cause a slightly different opinion as to what is intended or meant by a particular requirement. A thorough, thoughtful debate, including some historical perspective, background or case history with the issue, results in a cohesive melding of the minds. The result is an interpretation or position that makes sense and that can be applied by the various enforcement agencies that look at the fire protection and life safety features in a health care facility.
This process will bring a great deal of consistency to the myriad issues with which a health care facility must deal, often times with, multiple, key authorities having jurisdiction - TJC, DNV, CMS, local and state fire marshal’s and state health departments. The HITF, through the publications and information media of their respective organizations, will make public the results of their efforts to get the widest possible dissemination of their discussions.
Questions for the HITF must come in through one of the member organizations. The HITF meets at least once per year, normally during the NFPA Conference and Expo held every June. Task Force minutes, position statements and answers to questions will be available on the NFPA website and other publications.
Agendas/Minutes
- June 7, 2022, Boston, MA, Agenda, Minutes
- April 3, 2020, Conference Call, Agenda, Draft Minutes
- March 30, 2020, Agenda, Minutes
- June 18, 2019, Agenda, Minutes
- June 12, 2018, Agenda, Minutes
- June 6, 2017, Boston, MA, Agenda, Minutes
- June 15, 2016, Las Vegas, NV, Agenda, Minutes
- June 23, 2015, Chicago, IL, Agenda, Minutes
- June 10, 2014, Las Vegas, NV, Agenda, Minutes
- June 11, 2013, Chicago, IL, Agenda, Minutes
- June 10, 2013, Chicago, IL, Optional meeting, Minutes
- June 12, 2012, Las Vegas, Agenda, Minutes
- June 14, 2011, Boston, MA, Agenda, Minutes
- June 8, 2010, Las Vegas, NV, Agenda, Minutes
- November 19, 2009, Washington, DC, Agenda, Minutes
- June 9, 2009, Chicago, IL, Agenda, Minutes
- December 9, 2008, Oakbrook Terrace, IL, Agenda, Supplemental Agenda, Minutes
- June 3, 2008, Las Vegas, NV, Agenda, Minutes
- December 5, 2007, Washington, DC, Agenda, Minutes
- June 5, 2007, Boston, MA, Agenda, Minutes
- December 8, 2006, Baltimore, MD, Agenda, Minutes
- June 6, 2006, Orlando, FL, Agenda, Minutes
- June 7, 2005, Las Vegas, NV, Minutes
- November 16, 2004, Miami, FL, Minutes
- May 19, 2004, Salt Lake City, UT, Minutes
- November 19, 2003, Reno, NV, Minutes
- May 20, 2003, Dallas, TX, Minutes
- November 19, 2002, Atlanta, GA, Minutes
- May 21, 2002, Minneapolis, MN, Minutes
- November 13, 2001, Dallas, TX, Minutes
- May 15, 2001, Anaheim, CA, Minutes
- November 14, 2000, Lake Buena Vista, FL, Minutes
- May 16, 2000, Denver, CO, Minutes
- November 16, 1999, New Orleans, LA, Minutes
- May 18, 1999, Baltimore, MD, Minutes
- April 8, 1999, Oak Brook Park, IL, Minutes
- September 10, 1998, Park Ridge, IL, Minutes
Interpretations
- HITF Interpretations, June 2018
- HITF Interpretations, June 2016
- HITF Interpretations, January 2014
- HITF Interpretations, June 2011
- HITF Interpretations, June 2010
- HITF Interpretations, November 2009
- HITF Interpretation, June 2009
- HITF Interpretation, December 2008
- HITF Interpretation June 2008
- HITF Interpretation, December 2007
- HITF Interpretation, June 2007
- HITF Interpretations, December 2006
- HITF Interpretations, June 2006
- HITF Interpretation 4A and 4C
- HITF Interpretation January 2004
- HITF Interpretation, May 2003
- HITF Interpretation, November 2000
- HITF Interpretation, November 1999
- HITF Interpretation, November 1998
- HITF Interpretation, September 1998
Membership
The 15 member organizations are:
American Health Care Association (AHCA)
- Ajay V. Prasad – Jensen Hughes (Principal)
- David R. Hood – Jensen Hughes (Alternate)
American Society for Healthcare Engineering (ASHE)
- Chad E. Beebe – American Society for Healthcare Engineering (Principal)
- David A. Dagenais – Wentworth Douglas Hospital (Alternate)
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)
- Martin Casey – Centers for Medicare/Medicaid Services (Alternate)
Department of Defense (DoD)
- G. Brian Prediger – US Army Corps of Engineers (Principal)
- Justin A. Schwartz – US Army Corps of Engineers (Principal)
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)
- Peter A. Larrimer, P.E. – Department of Veterans Affairs (Principal)
- David P. Klein, P.E. – Department of Veterans Affairs (Alternate)
Det Norske Veritas Healthcare (DNVH)
- Clinton Butts – Det Norske Veritas Healthcare (DNVGL)(Principal)
- Brennan Scott – Det Norske Veritas Healthcare (DNVGL)(Alternate)
Accreditation Commission for Health Care (ACHC)
- Richard L. Parker – Accreditation Commission for Health Care (Principal)
Indian Health Service (IHS) - VACANT
International Fire Marshals Association (IFMA)
- Kenneth E. Bush – Maryland State Fire Marshal’s Office (Principal)
- Kim L. Osborn – Michigan Department of Labor and Economic Growth (Alternate)
The Joint Commission (TJC)
- Herman McKenzie – The Joint Commission (Principal)
- Tim Markijohn – The Joint Commission (Alternate)
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)
- Gregory E. Harrington, P.E. – NFPA Staff (Principal)
State Health Care Agency (SHA)
- Charles Schlegel – Pennsylvania Department of Health (Principal)
- John L. Williams – Washington State Department of Health (Alternate)
Chair - Life Safety Code Committee on Healthcare Occupancies
- William Koffel – Koffel Associates, Inc.
Chair - Healthcare Facilities Correlating Committee
Chair - NFPA Health Care Section
- Jim Peterkin – TLC Engineering Solutions, Inc.